Learning to use the potty or toilet is an important milestone for young children as it’s one of the first steps towards independence. As a parent, you may have many questions and concerns about when and how to start potty training your child. For example, when is the best time to start? What’s the best method? Is my child too young to start? And what are the signs of readiness?
What does the science say about timing? Interestingly, the timing of potty training can vary depending on culture. In many parts of the world, toilet training begins within weeks of birth. In contrast, in Western countries like the UK, children may continue to wear nappies until they’re around 3-4 years old. However, before World War II, most British children were out of nappies by 18 months.
While some people worry that early potty training (before 24 months) can cause behavioural problems or personality disorders, there’s no scientific evidence to support this claim. One reason why early training has a bad reputation is confusion between “when to train” and “how to train.” Many people believe that early training involves harsh and persistent methods, but this isn’t necessarily true. When parents use gentle, age-appropriate methods, early training can be safe and effective.
Advantages and disadvantages of potty training at different ages
Infants (0-12 months)
In some cultures, such as those in India, China, and East Africa, parents traditionally begin potty training their babies in early infancy. By recognising their baby’s body signals, parents can anticipate when their baby needs to go and hold them over a sink, bowl, toilet, or the open ground. They then make a characteristic sound or gesture while the baby goes. The baby learns to associate this sign with discharging and eventually learns to hold back until they hear/see the sign. Infant toilet training is more modest than later toilet training, and the goal is to stay dry with parental supervision.
Traditionally, infant potty training begins during the first three months after birth. Some recommend a later start (3-6 months), when babies go less frequently and can sit up on their own, so they can be trained with a potty chair. Training can also start between 6-12 months, but some experts argue that it can be more difficult when the infant becomes more mobile and less likely to sit still on a potty chair. Furthermore, older babies may have become used to wearing nappies and may ignore their body signals.
Benefits of this early training include parents no longer needing to spend time or energy on nappy changing, saving money, preventing nappy rashes, and enhancing children’s mastery and self-esteem.
Older infants and young toddlers (12-18 months)
For children between 12-18 months old, breaking the nappy habit can be challenging. Toddlers may also be too excited to sit still on a potty chair. In one study, children aged 15-19 months were more resistant to sitting on potty chairs than younger and older children. However, children under 18 months are often eager to please adults, making them more receptive to training.
Potty training after 18 months
Most children are not ready to begin training until 18-24 months. This recommendation is based on the idea that children should show signs of toilet readiness before potty training begins, such as being able to stay dry for two hours at a time, understanding and following verbal instructions, and being interested in underwear. However, the answer to how long to wait depends on the goal of training. If the parent’s goal is for their child to go to the bathroom and sit on the potty by themselves, then waiting until the child can walk is necessary. But if the goal is more modest, such as staying dry, then waiting for signs of advanced readiness is not necessary.
Potty training after 24 months
For many Western children, “potty training age” means 24 months or beyond. Unfortunately, there hasn’t been much research on whether this is beneficial. One study suggested that an earlier potty training age (between 18-24 months) was associated with longer total training durations. Other research suggests that earlier training helps protect kids from developing bladder problems later in life. Still, it’s important to note that studies regarding this matter have been limited, and it’s difficult to draw conclusions.
So, there you have it! When it comes to potty training, timing is essential, but don’t let it stress you out. Remember that every child is unique, and what works for one child might not work for another. And most importantly, have fun! Celebrate your child’s achievements and don’t be too hard on yourself or them. With patience, persistence, and love, you and your child will get through this.







